President John Catanzara informed members that he is finally doing
something about the hostile takeover of Forensics by the private
company Ron Smith & Associates. The room seemed cautiously
optimistic — or at least as optimistic as you can be when you’ve heard a
version of that sentence before.
To his credit,
acknowledging the issue out loud is a step in the right direction.
Whether that step leads anywhere beyond the microphone is, of course,
the part everyone is waiting to see.
Then things got… interesting.
After
wrapping up what can only be described as a highlight reel of his own
accomplishments, EJ stepped up to the mic. She started by thanking him
for his “hard work” — which, given what followed, may go down as one of
the more polite setups in recent meeting history.
She then asked a simple question: whether he had charged his trips to Jamaica on the FOP credit card. The reaction said more than the answer.
John
looked like he got caught with his hand in the cookie jar. He
immediately denied it — flat out. EJ followed up by suggesting that if
that were true, there should be no issue opening the financials back up
to the membership.
That’s when the story started changing.
John
claimed the financials were never open to members — which raised a few
eyebrows, considering he himself reviewed them when Kevin was President.
When that was pointed out, he pivoted again, saying members can’t see
the credit card statements because, before they were locked down,
someone saw a $5,000 steak dinner charge and “blew it out of
proportion.”
EJ’s response was simple: “But you still spent $5,000 on a steak dinner.” John tried to reframe it as a dinner for retirees. EJ didn’t budge: “It’s still a $5,000 steak dinner.”
At that point, the wheels came off.
Unable
to win that argument, John pivoted hard — this time to attacking EJ
personally, bringing up CR numbers related to her social media activity.
There are growing concerns that complaints have been encouraged in
response to her speaking out. He then suggested the Lodge has spent too much money providing her legal defense for IAD statements. EJ
fired back with the obvious question: how much has the Lodge spent
defending him over his own posts? Posts that forced him tor retire
before he was fired. When she asked if it was in the neighborhood of a million dollars, John said he “didn’t know.”
Which, at this point, seems to be the most consistent answer of the day.