This is ridiculous. Someone just burned a $4 million dollar test. Here's how we heard it went down - someone closer to the investigation can fill in the finer points:
- Part 2 of the exam consisted of an "Oral Board." Test takers were shown a short clip and then asked to respond to the clip within a set time limit. A dozen or so clips were shown with time to answer the scenarios between each clip
- Some proctor misunderstood the directions and told test takers that they had to watch the entire series of video clips one after the other and then answer all the questions one after the other at the end of the entire run
- Sergeants who protested were told they could either perform the test as administered (whether wrong or not) or they could leave the testing area and receive ZERO credit for Part 2 of the exam. Needless to say, they took the test, and we heard at least one lawsuit has been filed as of this evening.
Today, this FAX came out:
- Fax Message # 071913 01 May 07
POLICE LIEUTENANT EXAMINATION ANNOUNCEMENT ***ASSESSMENT EXERCISE RE-TEST**
Note: The re-test will consist of the same questions administered on Jan. 6,2007. For those taking the re-test on June 23, 2007, the evaluation of the oral portion of Assessment Exercise will be based on your June 23, 2007 performance; your Jan. 6, 2007 performance will not be evaluated. For those that choose not to re-test on June 23, 2007, the evaluation of the oral portion of the Assessment Exercise will be based on your Jan. 6, 2007 performance.
A re-test. Consisting of the EXACT same questions that were already given. Hell, if we had the questions 7 weeks in advance to every promotional test we've ever been eligible for, we'd be Captains at least a year ago.
How is this not going to be a HUGE federal lawsuit? How is it that Noelle Brennan, the Federal oversight person in charge of all manner of promotions and hiring NOT blasting the City and it's testing firm (was it Ernst & Young again?) First up, anyone who has any doubts whatsoever that they may have missed a certain question or two damn well better sign up for this "do-over." And anyone who thinks they might be able to "tweak" an answer or two for a few extra bonus points better do so.
This is a fuck up of monumental proportions. How anyone can even consider this anything resembling a legit test is beyond us. Does this feed into the rumors we heard a few years ago that the Department was seriously looking into making all Lieutenant promotions by "merit" and resumes like Captain promotions?
The mind boggles. Hello? Investigative media? $4 million dollars and who knows how many lawyers fees will be eaten up by this one. Anyone?
UPDATE: Who wants to bet on the possibility that there might be a copy of a certain DVD containing, oh let's just say, SEVEN scenarios, that somehow made it out of the control of the testing firm and is currently circulating amongst test takers? After all, this is Chicago.
Labels: department issues, promotions